Tuesday, July 21, 2009

Teoh Beng Hock's death

I believe that anyone who read the newspaper for the past few days will be aware of Teoh Beng Hock's death. I have something to say but know that whatever I say in this post are all my personal opinions. You may disagree and put up an argument in the comments section, which I gladly welcome you to do so.

Before I begin I would like to categorise my views directed towards MACC and Pakatan Rakyat.

For MACC, I think it's apparent that they are biased. They chose to investigate on Pakatan's trivial cases instead of investigating cases like the RM12.5 billion Port Klang Free Zone (PKFZ) Scandal or the
RM24 million Khir Toyo's palace. Moreover those that were arrested last week were all from Pakatan. Despite that, due to the very fact that Teoh Beng Hock's mysterious death of falling off from the MACC building, MACC has much to answer for, and I doubt that they can nor should run away from their responsibility.

As for Teoh Beng Hock's death, sorry to say yet I must, he died a victim but not a hero, thus he deserves to be pitied but not honoured. However, what I saw is that, he was greatly honoured by all Pakatan members especially DAP (since he's a DAP member) as if he's a spartan hero of some sort. I know that he's the first one that died in the MACC building after he was taken into MACC for 'investigation', bla bla bla. The conclusion is, he died, and he's innocent (well that's what everyone says, I have no idea). But come to think of it, how many people died innocently over the years. Who will seek justice for them? Nobody other than their family and friends probably. The fact that Teoh Beng Hock's death is such a shocking news is because it has been politicised by Pakatan, since he is a DAP member.

I am not against Pakatan's action to pressure the government. And true, no pressure, no actions taken. But I think they went overboard.

Alright I'm gonna quote my conversation (in Facebook, funny huh) with a friend doing LLB in University of Nottingham, UK regarding this issue, since what I'm gonna write here is pretty much similar to what I said there. Here we go :

Darwin Tan : got fed up with politics.


Khar-Yue Phoon : Why?


Darwin Tan : cause of the MACC case got politicised.

Khar-Yue Phoon : Yeah loh. It's UMNO's fault for that.

Darwin Tan : not really. both parties got their own faults in it.

Khar-Yue Phoon : I like your well-balanced and diplomatic answer.

But we both know deep down inside who the real culprit is for politicising this incident. For starters, take a read at what UMNO owned dailies (Utusan, Berita Mingguan, MM) had to say. Juxtapose that with MI or Mkini's articles.

The difference cannot be any more clearer.

Darwin Tan : Utusan is a joke so u can screw that aside. If you r talking about the whole picture, then yes, UMNO started it somehow by commencing the 'arrest'. But what I look upon is that the death of that guy is sad, but what makes it more tragic is that his death itself is politicised by Pakatan, and I got sicked of it.

Khar-Yue Phoon : Perhaps there is a negative connotation attached to the word 'politicise'.

Politicisation normally brings about a negative impact, as evident in UMNO dailies who associate MACC critics as racists and anti-Malay.

However, it is worth noting that not all politicisation is bad. This is apparent in Pakatan's attempt to publicise Teoh's death in the hopes of strengthening civil rights; raising awareness of the abuse of powers of government and promoting accountability and transparency. To me, I cannot see any wrong in that. After all, Teoh should not die for nothing. If he did, it would be even sadder for Malaysians.


But yeah, I agree with you whole-heartedly that UMNO owned dailies are a joke! HAHAHA

Darwin Tan : No, what I meant was, pressure must be given, else no actions will be taken. But they went overboard. Now the newspaper is publishing things regarding his death for days. DAP cares, politicians care, BH's family cares, some people care but not many of them. To most, it's just a nobody died falling off from the MACC building. People will get bored of the case after some time. And it is really sad that it costs death to actually raise awareness amongst the people. The key question is, does Pakatan do all these purely for justice, or there are hidden political agendas at the back? Man I hate political parties.

Khar-Yue Phoon : That is the beauty of a civilised democracy.

IF Pakatan has hidden political agendas and the Rakyat saw through that, rest assured that they will voted OUT of their political office in the next general elections.

A practical example would be the recent by-election in Manek Urai. Despite PAS being the victor, the margin of votes between them and UMNO was very small. The internal bickering within PAS was causing frustrated voters to choose UMNO instead.


Like I said, all is fair and square.


Darwin Tan : The thing is, their political agenda coincidentally goes the same way as BH's death. It's a good chance for publicity by shouting "Justice for Beng Hock", to reveal the truth of the death and at the same time persuading the people to vote for them to take over the government.

I am not saying that it is wrong. This is politics after all. There is
no right or wrong. But the fact that they have agendas behind a funeral scene and stuff just makes me sick.

Btw, there is no way pakatan getting voted off at the moment. Pick one between Najib and Anwar, you know which to pick isn't it. And we all know how corrupted BN is, is there a better choice than Pakatan at the moment?

That's all for the debate in Facebook, and we continued our talk in MSN. Anyway I've highlighted our points in the conversation in bold.

In summary, I agree that they should pressure the government to establish a Royal Commission of Investigation to investigate the matter for everyone's sake, but the fact that they come up with demonstrations and all sorts of banner and activities to condemn MACC show that they have overacted.

I agree with one of my other friend that, "There is a time to grieve, but never forget that governance is the top priority." It might appear that everyone cares about Teoh Beng Hock's death, but in truth majority of those are his family, DAP and Pakatan supporters. A big part of the society merely looks at it as a new phenomenon in Malaysia, nothing more. To gain the votes of the minority that seeks justice for Teoh Beng Hock's death, they can go on with more demonstrations and press conferences. But to win the hearts of all Malaysians, they will need to stabilise their governance, ensuring that their constituencies prosper and strengthening the alliance between DAP, PAS & PKR other than seeking vengeance and justice. It's all about balance.

May justice prevails and may our country prospers under the right hands.

3 comments:

  1. I agree with you that there is a fine line between political gain and fighting for justice, and it takes a lot of wisdom to discern between the two and a lot of integrity to practice what one truly believe in.

    Yet, I want to echo with Khar-Yue that not all politicization is bad. Every campaigns has an agenda, the only difference is what the agenda is. On Teoh Beng Hock's case, I would say that he did not die in vain if, at the very least, his death would stir up the hearts of many Malaysians to rise up to do something to save the nation from the detioriating principles and corrupted governance. And it IS our responsibility to see to it that his death would not be like whistle thrown in the air, but have practical positive impact to the well being of the country.

    Masato, I think that you are well thought young talent, it is a beautiful character, yet please don't let it holds you back from taking prompt action for the right cause.

    Lastly, a quote for you, from the 'kingdom of heaven' movie.
    'None of us choose our end, A king can move a man; a father can claim a son...But your soul is in your keeping alone, when you stand before God, You cannot say 'But I was told by others to do thus' or that virtue was not convenient at the time. This will not suffice'
    At the end of the day, we are answerable to our God and to Him only.

    May justice prevails and may our country prospers under the right hands.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for your great comment. But I would like to clarify a few things, if you don't mind.

    Q : Do I think that the politicisation of TBH's death is wrong?
    A : Morally, yes. Politically, no.

    Q : Do I want a change of government?
    A : Hell yes, else don't even call Malaysia a democratic country.

    So...don't worry, I shall do what I must for the country. Yet as I said, the very fact that a person is used as a tool even in death is just sickening, at least to me.

    But in an economic perspective as my friend mentioned in the MSN, perhaps his death is a kind of scarce resources. We must utilise his death, don't waste it. Although he said it made him sound like a bastard by saying this, but to be honest, I agree with it, if you see it in an objective view.

    Rest assured though, I met some really funny and interesting veteran members of DAP today. That really gave me some renewed vigour to go on.

    ReplyDelete
  3. maylaysia shud change gov long long long long time edi la everyday also this kind of news sien edi lo everyone eat money here and dere,say wan to investigate who took it in the end no result also always like that wan sien edi la...

    Haiz fed up with maylaysia gov long time ago edi first abdullah(eat money like hell but no action towards country at all) then second najib(show oni also eating behind the scene havent show true face yet)

    When is it gona be a proper PM to take over?? so many years edi haiz =_=


    PS: wah darwin long time no see u now go into politics kaokao edi wad happen lol to many free time ka?? dun get into trouble can edi if not like the online blogger kena tangkap by ISA or IRS hahahhahahahaha

    PS:btw using my moms google acc since i dun have 1 ><

    Your Friend
    Jye Wei

    ReplyDelete